2. Gut-it-Out Walk vs the Mets, 2000
The Yankees won a thrilled over the Mets in Game 1 of the 2000 World Series thanks to Paul O’Neill’s patience.
Paul O’Neill could do it with the bat, sure, chopping down on the ball and taking a lumbering no-look jog around the bases over and over again.
But the threat of O’Neill’s stamina was enough to send any opposing pitcher into a frenzy, and he completely flipped the 2000 Subway Series when he mentally outworked Mets closer Armando Benitez.
Down 3-2 with one out and nobody on in the ninth inning, O’Neill refused to relent, doggedly grinding out a 10-pitch walk against one of the game’s hardest throwers (and a known erratic one, too).
Luis Polonia, the very man whom O’Neill robbed in the ’96 Series, singled next, followed by a Jose Vizcaino single and a bases-loaded Chuck Knoblauch sac fly.
And just like that, we were destined for a 13-inning Yankee win.
Much like everything O’Neill did, his walk turned a tough series into an eventual five-game triumph, which looks very different on paper than it felt in reality. On this day, the grinder’s earned his due.