Yankees: 5 Prospects Most Affected by Minor League Season Cancellation

The New York Yankees prospect pool took a hit when the minor league season was cancelled.

As we long have expected, news dropped on Tuesday that the 2020 Minor League Baseball season will not take place, leaving many Yankees prospects in the lurch.

Unlike MLB action (which will be constantly threatened by the pandemic in the ensuing weeks, too), MiLB teams had no method to subsist without fans in the stands, and once their gate receipts were destined to be null and void, there was no point in completing the campaign.

Well, except for that little insignificant detail called…player development. Some Yankees prospects on the verge of big league success have now been doomed to the 60-man pool in Scranton/Wilkes-Barre, while others still won’t be doing much of anything.

We hope no one’s growth is forever stunted, but these five Yankees top prospects would’ve vastly preferred not to take the year off.

5. Deivi Garcia

New York Yankees top pitching prospect Deivi Garcia needed a full 2020 season.

Deivi Garcia rose all the way to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre in 2020 as a 20-year-old. Buoyed by a strong showing in Tampa and Trenton, he was the NYY’s Futures Game nominee.

But once he got to the highest level, his numbers sputtered — 1-3, 5.40 ERA, 20 walks and 45 Ks in 40 innings. Yes, he’s just a kid. But he did nothing to prove he was ready for a big league cameo, nor did he assuage concerns that his small stature will eventually force him into a relief role and short spurts of effectiveness at the highest levels.

Garcia’s shown exceptional strikeout stuff, but has a ways to go to prove he’s a starter, and not simply an electric relief option. If he gets the chance to dominate with the Yankees this season, it likely won’t be in the rotation — and that’s not really what he needed in 2020, with plenty left to prove at Triple-A.

3. Anthony Seigler

We’re not sure what Yankees prospect Anthony Seigler is at this point.

Ahh, a non-pitching prospect! Yes, we’re covering exactly one of those. Apparently, the Yankees have promising non-pitchers. Who knew?

Though it’s been long-assumed that Anthony Seigler, the team’s 2018 first-round pick, would have no 2020 season with which to defend himself, the Seigler vs. Austin Wells battle has officially begun.

New York used their 2020 first-rounder on Wells, a bat-first catcher from Arizona, leaving top pitching options like Louisville’s Bobby Miller on the table. Clearly, that reflects that they believe in Wells, and are having second thoughts about Seigler, who could’ve really used a year of development in 2020.

The kid played just 30 games at Charleston in 2019 in what was supposed to be his first full season, and hit a paltry .175, failing to connect on a single home run. He missed the final two months of the season with a patella fracture after a wayward foul tip, and will now see that absence extended by a full year.

His Single-A manager was left impressed with his athletic ability last year, but we didn’t see much of it. Now, Seigler loses both a season and a chance to defend himself.

2. Luis Medina

Luis Medina won’t be able to build on his wild 2019 season.

New York’s 10th-ranked prospect Luis Medina posted one of the all-around wildest stat lines we saw at any level in 2019.

The 21-year-old is one of the NYY’s most electric options, but also clearly ranks as mega-raw. At Single-A Charleston, Medina whiffed 115 in 93 innings with his shoulder-bending curve. Nice! The bad? He also walked 67, and went 1-8 with an even 6.00 ERA. A late-season promotion to Tampa (you ever post a 6.00 ERA and get promoted?) yielded different results — in two starts and 10.2 innings pitched, Medina allowed just a single earned run and whiffed 12.

Needless to say, the team brass was very excited to see him operate at that level for a full season — then, nature intervened.

Of the team’s top 10 options, Medina likely has the most stuff still left to harness, but will no longer get a chance to do so in 2020.

1. Roansy Contreras

New York Yankees prospect Roansy Contreras doesn’t have options in 2020.

When the 60-man player pool was announced for the 2020 Yankees season, many expected it to be more expansive than ever in terms of top prospect deployment. After all, if someone couldn’t participate in a full campaign, they might as well be in the pool, right?

That’s why it was so surprising that Roansy Contreras, New York’s 19th-ranked prospect and the most advanced of the team’s 20-year-olds, wasn’t included.

Unlike his out-of-control cohorts, Contreras spins and spots his 92-to-95 MPH fastball quite well, walking just 36 in 132.1 at Charleston last season. Though he’s got a propensity for the fly ball, he’s certainly more pro-ready than most of the erratic pitchers around his age.

If the Yankees needed a pitcher in a pinch, it actually seems like Contreras would provide more value than someone like Abreu.

Instead, he’s lost for the 2020 season, and his future remains a mystery.