New York Yankees outfield is crowded; what to do?

1 of 5

With Spring Training officially here, it is time for the positional battles to begin. The New York Yankees, although considered one of the better teams in the American League, still have a few holes to fill before Opening Day.

The Yankees are still seeking a starting second baseman and a starting third baseman. And yes, I know that it may seem as though the Yanks are ready for Miguel Andújar to take over the reigns at third; and I am sure we will see Gleyber Torres called up at some point to make some starts at second.

But with the addition of Brandon Drury, the battles tighten even more. Drury having the ability to play both second and third will be resourceful down the stretch while also limiting the playing time of both Andújar and Torres.

But why dig into the farm system? Why call up Torres, who had Tommy John Surgery halfway through last season?

Perhaps the better route would be to look at the crowded Yankee outfield. After the acquisition of Giancarlo Stanton back in December, the Yankees have six potential starting outfielders. The problem here is that only three can start each game, four if you include the DH spot.

That’ll leave the Yankees with two starting-worthy outfielders on the bench, wasting not only their abilities and development but also payroll.

And for those of you that want the young prospects to start in the majors over the “washed up” players, one of those benched outfielders would most likely be the former first-round pick, Clint Frazier.

I am proposing a positional change of some of these outfielders. Now I know what some of you are thinking but hear me out. Added depth couldn’t hurt the team, plus this wouldn’t be the first time a player would be experimenting with a new position either to play more or just to improve the team.

Hatteberg, Doolittle, Santana, Mauer, Desmond

When the Oakland Athletics signed Scott Hatteberg back in 2002, they had the idea to teach him how to play first base instead of catcher; because they needed a first baseman and wanted his bat in the lineup.

Remember the scene from the movie “Money Ball” where Brad Pitt (Billy Beane) does his best to convince Chris Pratt (Scott Hatteberg) to switch positions?

Now Hatteberg was not a great defensive first baseman, in fact, he was downright lousy; but the Athletics were a very successful team that season, winning over 100 games. And this was not the last time the Athletics have moved a player to a different position for the benefit of the team.

Billy Beane, as we all know, was not the conventional general manager and now VP of baseball operations for the A’s. In switching Sean Doolittle from a first baseman to a relief pitcher, Beane created an All-Star closer with a career ERA just around 3.00.

There are hundreds of other examples of this successfully happening; from Carlos Santana playing primarily first base now, after having been a catcher early on in his career — to Joe Mauer doing the same. Even

Even Ian Desmond initially played almost exclusively at shortstop, but now splits his time between first base and left field; having played shortstop once in the past two seasons.

The question is who should or could play the infield for the Yankees?

Brett Gardner and Jacoby Ellsbury

Well, since both Brett Gardner and Jacoby Ellsbury are left-handed, the only other position which they should play, if any at all, would be first base. But something tells me that the two of them should stay in the outfield.

Being smaller, faster guys, both Gardner and Ellsbury seem to be the perfect fit as outfielders. To top that off, having each won a Gold Glove Award for their outfield work, Gardner and Ellsbury were seen at one point as being within the top three of defensive outfielders in a season.

For these reasons as well as any others I am sure you can think of, Gardner and Ellsbury should stay in the outfield.

So where does that leave us now? Well, we still have to look at the twin towers of Judge and Stanton, as well as the young Clint Frazier and the record holder for the fastest throw from an outfielder, Aaron Hicks.

Being that Hicks saved 15 runs last season in just 88 games, he seems to be a sound option in the outfield. Not to mention those 15 runs came in eighth in MLB of all outfielders, Mookie Betts coming in first with 31 defensive runs saved.

But do not overlook the uber-athletic Hicks, as he averages almost the same number of runs saved on defense per game as Betts.

Aaron Hicks and Clint Frazier

Hicks also is almost identical to the average height and weight of all MLB outfield Gold Glove winners. He also has decent speed, and as we are all familiar with his cannon for an arm. Hicks is a good fit for the Yankees’ outfield, being capable of playing all three outfield positions.

But if Hicks were to remain in the outfield, then where does Frazier land?

Well, Frazier is young, 23 years of age. He is also very aggressive and athletic, as we can all see from watching him play. Many scouts see future power out of Frazier as a result of his build and aggression. It seems only logical to try to figure out a way to get the phenom more playing time.

But Frazier might not find this playing time in the outfield. Being right-handed could help Frazier in this aspect as he could potentially play second base, third base or shortstop.

Nowhere near as large as his counterparts Judge and Stanton, Frazier does not seem to be the person fit to play first, especially with his above average speed. Therefore, I propose Frazier try his hand at second.

Seen by some scouts as having difficulty tracking balls in the outfield, an infield swap could be for the best. On top of that, “good” fielding second baseman is not all that great. The average Gold Glove second baseman saves under two runs a season. That’s not all that much.

If Frazier were to hit two more solo home runs than last season, he would surmount the average defensive ability of “great” fielding second baseman.

To put these numbers in comparison, Gold Glove winner and former Yankees’ second baseman, Robinson Cano, saved zero runs last season on defense.

Plus, with Frazier at second, he will have the shortest throw to make to first. The primary difficulty in playing second base would be turning double plays, but with Frazier’s aggressive attitude, perhaps he will only see this as another challenge to surmount.

Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton

Of the remaining “outfielders,” Stanton and Judge do not fit the typical middle infield physique. That being said, anything is possible; maybe Stanton would be a great fielding second baseman. But judging by previous performances and size of the “twin towers,” the two look most similar to Gold Glove first and third basemen.

Both very tall and muscular, Judge and Stanton match with the larger generic profile of the corner infielders. But besides the physicality of good corner infielders, generally, mediocre fielding corner infielders still make do and perform well. Or at least we think they do.

With Spring Training officially here, it is time for the positional battles to begin. The New York Yankees, although considered one of the better teams in the American League, still have a few holes to fill before Opening Day.

Hatteberg, Doolittle, Santana, Mauer, Desmond

Brett Gardner and Jacoby Ellsbury

Aaron Hicks and Clint Frazier

Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton

Schedule