Three Ways the Yankees Could Dump Jacoby Ellsbury This Winter

Detroit Tigers

By all indications, the Detroit Tigers are trying to cut payroll this winter, so them taking on a big money deal like Ellsbury’s seems counterintuitive. At the same time, the Tigers have a clear need in center field, with Anthony Gose and Jacoby Jones currently their best internal candidates.

They are still trying to compete in 2017, so if they were able to unload one of their own disappointing big money deals in exchange, there could be a fit. The Tigers have plenty of big contracts to choose from, but most of them are probably too good to swap for Ellsbury.

Their most onerous deals are Miguel Cabrera, who is still owed $212 million even if his 2024 and 2025 options don’t vest, and Justin Verlander, who was a serious AL Cy Young candidate last year. Despite the boatloads of money owed to them, anyone who wants to acquire them would probably need to part with some top prospects as well, making a deal for either guy unlikely.

The other two nine figure deals they have on the books might be a better fit following disappointing seasons. Jordan Zimmerman signed his five year $110 million contract just last offseason, and given the Yankees’ futile search for controllable starting pitching this winter, it’s possible they could see him as a viable bounce back candidate at age 31, even after pitching to a disappointing 4.87 ERA and 4.42 FIP in 105.1 IP while dealing with neck and groin injuries.

From 2012-2015, Zimmerman was one of the National League’s most consistent starters with the Nationals, accumulating a 3.13 ERA and 3.33 FIP over 129 starts over those four seasons, making him worth a combined 16.8 wins above replacement in that span according to Baseball-Reference.

Another possibility with the Tigers is their other big free agent signing from last year, Justin Upton, who is most likely available after hitting just .246/.310/.465 (108 OPS+) with 31 home runs and 87 RBI in 626 plate appearances

Aside from his flashy power numbers, Upton’s performance was pretty ugly in 2016, but he’s four years younger than Ellsbury and would give the Yanks another much-needed power bat. He’s owed $110.5 million over the next five years, so a straight one-for-one would help Detroit’s front office save around $20 million. New York would likely still need to sweeten the pot with a solid prospect or two for this to work.

Texas Rangers

After the sad ending to Prince Fielder‘s career in 2016, the Rangers have just one under-performing big money player who could be a fair return in an Ellsbury swap, right fielder Shin-Soo Choo.

If this trade were to go down, the irony would be a lot of fun, because the Yankees reportedly pursued both Ellsbury and Choo during the 2013-2014 offseason before eventually choosing the speedy center fielder. A deal like this would allow them to correct their mistake.

To be fair, Choo hasn’t played up to expectations either in his first three seasons since signing. He’s hit a combined .258/.359/.419 (112 OPS+) with 42 home runs over the last three years. Offensively, he’s been much more productive than Ellsbury, especially in the power department, which is much more valuable to New York right now than another glove-first guy.

Choo is pretty terrible defensively at this point, but the Yankees could probably live with him or Matt Holliday in left for a season, shifting Brett Gardner to center, and then move Choo to DH full-time when Holliday’s deal is up.

It’s also worth noting that Choo had his last above-average season more recently than Ellsbury, when he hit .276/.375/.463 (125 OPS+) with 22 home runs and 82 RBI in 653 plate appearances. He also has a clear explanation for his 2016 dip in production as he was plagued by hamstring, calf, and back injuries before fracturing his forearm in mid-August.

Chicago Cubs

Jason Heyward was rumored to be the only big name free agent the Yankees would consider committing big money to last offseason because his youth made him a nice asset for a club on the cusp of a serious rebuild.

More from Yankees News

• CC Sabathia defends Yankees’ massive Aaron Judge contract
• Scott Boras closed Yankees-Carlos Rodón deal from Fenway Park, put cherry on top
• Orioles are bailing out Yankees and AL East by botching free agency
• Guy who caught Aaron Judge record HR ball cost himself tons of money in auction
• Did Yankees fans bully Hal Steinbrenner into signing Aaron Judge, Carlos Rodón?

It also came out last spring that New York came close to acquiring Heyward the previous winter as well, prior to the trade that sent him from Atlanta to St. Louis. The proposed deal was a ten-player that would have included Luis Severino, Aaron Judge, and Gary Sanchez.

Even after an ugly season in which Heyward hit .230/.306/.325 (70 OPS+) in 592 plate appearances and was relegated to a part-time player in the postseason, you have to believe there are those in the Yankees front office who would have some residual interest in bringing him on board.

Heyward is still just 27 years old and did win his fourth National League Gold Glove award. 2016 was the first time in the young man’s career that he was not an above average regular by Baseball-Reference’s wins above replacement metric. He’s accumulated 32.7 WAR over his seven-year career, and was worth over six wins each of the previous two seasons, which is superstar caliber production.

While Chicago signed Jon Jay to a one-year deal to patch over the hole left in center field by Dexter Fowler‘s departure. Even in his diminished state, Ellsbury would be a pretty big upgrade defensively and at the top of the lineup at a time when the Cubbies are gearing up for another championship run. It also helps them long term by shedding almost $100 million in committed money.

Next: Rotation or Pen for These Yankees Pitchers?

Despite his poor performance in 2016, I’d much rather have Heyward than Ellsbury over the next few years, but this is probably the craziest of the four swaps I’ve proposed here because of how much more money the Yankees would be taking back at a time when they are trying to get under the luxury tax and trimming payroll. It would certainly be a fun gamble for New York though.