"Disrespecting to Flanny" Mandatory Credit: Paul Abell-US PRESSWIRE

The Yankees And Double Standards


On the heels of the events of the last week or so I thought I’d take a look at how the Yankees and double standards have come into play in MLB.

The first thing that caught my attention was Rafael Soriano and Untuckgate. I couldn’t fathom how a guy who untucked his jersey after he recorded a save garnered so much attention from the media. Who cares if he does that? MSM does, I soon realized. He was vilified by baseball purists as a player who broke the sacred “unwritten rules” by showing up an opponent. OK, whatever. Manager Joe Girardi said he had his closer’s back and that it didn’t bother him, which seemed to quash the controversy.

Soon thereafter, Reds closer Aroldis Chapman recorded a save and then proceeded to do somersaults from the pitcher’s mound. This didn’t seem to create as much of a stir as Soriano’s antics, which baffled me. There is no way that untucking a jersey is more of a slap in the face to an opponent than doing two somersaults from the pitcher’s mound. I just don’t get how Soriano’s theatrics rubbed people the wrong way more than Chapman’s did. If a Yankee did somersaults after recording a save everybody would be up in arms about how the team is ruining baseball, but since he’s not a Yankee it’s OK.

For the record, I don’t have a problem with either celebration and in fact I think it’s cool when players show emotion on the field. Just trying to illustrate how the two celebrations were received differently. Also, I know Chapman’s teammates reamed him out after the somersaults, but he didn’t really seem to get it bad from the media. That’s my point.

Another case is when Dewayne Wise jumped into the stands to make a catch on a foul ball against the Indians on Tuesday evening (and, to a lesser extent, when Jeter pretended to be hit by a pitch against the Rays late in the 2010 season). Everyone was saying how Wise should’ve told the ump that he didn’t even have the ball to keep the integrity of the sport, and Jeter should’ve said that the pitch hit his bat; in not doing so they were both deemed cheaters by fans and some sportswriters.

Poppycock, I say.

Nobody said boo when Jason Donald kept his mouth shut after Jim Joyce botched the call on the final out in Armando Galaraga’s “perfect” game. That’s quite the double standard.

How about when Ichiro hit a walk-off homer and, right before touching home plate, motioned toward his groin in a “suck it” manner? Or the Prince Fielder home run celebration when he was on the Brewers?* Can you imagine if A-Rod (or another Yankee) partook in such antics? There would be a lynch mob at said player’s house while certain baseball writers penned slam pieces about how the Yanks are ruining baseball.

*Again, I don’t have a problem with these types of celebrations — and actually think they’re very cool — I’m just trying to point out the hypocrisy of fans and MSM.

Perhaps the most glaring example of this double standard is how David Ortiz and Manny Ramirez tested positive for steroids in 2003 but denied it and never had any backlash. Ortiz made up some bogus excuse about vitamins and said he’s searching for the truth, and the subject was never brought up again by the media. Whereas a few Yankees owned up to it and are still getting slammed. That’s some example MLB is setting for the children — deny everything and you’re gravy, take responsibility and it’ll be raining shit on you for the rest of your life.

I guess them’s the breaks when you root/play for one of the most hated franchises in sports. Some things will never change.

Tags: Aroldis Chapman David Ortiz Derek Jeter Dewayne Wise Double Standards Ichiro Manny Ramirez New York Yankees Popular Prince Fielder Rafael Soriano Yankees

  • MHunterYGY

    I do agree that there are a lot of double standards in the MSM in general. However, a lot of it does depend on your perspective. Based on what I have seen and read, Chapman’s somersaults have garnered a lot more attention and criticism than the untuck. In fact, when I saw everyone talking about the untuck on Twitter a couple days ago, I didn’t know what they were talking about. Maybe in New York the perception of the MSM is different, but over here in California, I personally haven’t seen much hypocrisy, and for both Soriano and Wade, I haven’t heard anybody really criticizing their actions. Not that I follow the MSM that much, and much of it is just from Baseball Tonight, but my point still stands. It all kind of depends on your perspective.

  • MHunterYGY

    I do agree that there are a lot of double standards in the MSM in general. However, a lot of it does depend on your perspective. Based on what I have seen and read, Chapman’s somersaults have garnered a lot more attention and criticism than the untuck. In fact, when I saw everyone talking about the untuck on Twitter a couple days ago, I didn’t know what they were talking about. Maybe in New York the perception of the MSM is different, but over here in California, I personally haven’t seen much hypocrisy, and for both Soriano and Wade, I haven’t heard anybody really criticizing their actions. Not that I follow the MSM that much, and much of it is just from Baseball Tonight, but my point still stands. It all kind of depends on your perspective. 

    • Andrew Corselli

       @MHunterYGY I guess you’re right about Soriano and Chapman; it all depends on the coverage in your area. Although I feel all my other points are valid — Ichiro and Prince celebrations, and the Ortiz/Manny thing.

  • jkra0512_SK

    I like the celebrations, it’s what helps differentiate players from each other. Baseball needs personality and I can’t wait until the old crusties leave this game. While some of the old traditions are nice, most of them are outdated…

    • Andrew Corselli

       @jkra0512_SK Couldn’t agree more. Some traditions are cool, but there are some that just need to go.

  • Pingback: Bullpen wastes Nova’s effort, Yankees win streak ends at five - Yanks Go Yard