Yankees: Predicting which free agents they’ll bring back for the 2020 season
DH/1B Edwin Encarnacion
Encarnacion is hopeful to return to the lineup this weekend after suffering an oblique strain back on September 12th. I he can he’ll be back just in time to get a handful of at-bats under his belt before the postseason. Now whether he’ll be back with the club in 2020, that remains to be seen. The veteran slugger has a team option for $20M next season, but he also has a $5M buyout clause the Yankees can pay which would allow him to become a free agent.
Out of all the potential free agents on the roster, Encarnacion’s future in New York might be the toughest to predict. I think the Yankees would love to bring him back as their primary DH and part-time first baseman next season, but he’s probably not going to be their top priority when free agency begins. The focus will be on starting pitching and Aroldis Chapman if he becomes a free agent.
Based on his performance this season (34 HR, 86 RBI) Encarnacion is worth $20M for one more season, but the Yankees might not be willing to pay that high of a price when they already have guys like Stanton, Voit, and LeMahieu to take up the majority of the at-bats at first base and DH. That’s not even mentioning Miguel Andujar who could also figure into the mix if he changes positions.
Despite missing some time due to injury Encarnacion has been very productive for the Yankees hitting .249, with 13 HR and 37 RBI in just 44 games. He’ll be 37 next season and he also still has a lot left in the tank, but my guess is he won’t be back with the Yankees and they’ll invest their money ion starting pitching instead and guys like Gerrit Cole or Stephen Strasburg.
Prediction: The Yankees will pay the $5M buyout clause and Encarnacion will become a free agent.